Tuesday, September 15, 2015

The Man Who Closed the Asylums (Book Review)

Disclosure:  I received a copy of this book, at no cost to me, for review purposes.  All opinions in this post are my own.

The Man Who Closed the Asylums:  Franco Basaglia and the Revolution in Mental Health Care, written by John Foot, is dramatically different from any book I've ever reviewed.  I don't quite know what to say about it.  First, though, the publisher's blurb:
When the wind of the 1960s blew through the world of psychiatry

In 1961, when Franco Basaglia arrived outside the grim walls of the Gorizia asylum, on the Italian border with Yugoslavia, it was a place of horror, a Bedlam for the mentally sick and excluded, redolent of Basaglia’s own wartime experience inside a fascist gaol. Patients were frequently restrained for long periods, and therapy was largely a matter of electric and insulin shocks. The corridors stank, and for many of the interned the doors were locked for life. This was a concentration camp, not a hospital. 
Basaglia, the new Director, was expected to practise all the skills of oppression in which he had been schooled, but he would have none of this. The place had to be closed down by opening it up from the inside, bringing freedom and democracy to the patients, the nurses and the psychiatrists working in that “total institution.” 
Inspired by the writings of authors such as Primo Levi, R.D. Laing, Erving Goffman, Michel Foucault and Frantz Fanon, and the practices of experimental therapeutic communities in the UK, Basaglia’s seminal work as a psychiatrist and campaigner in Gorizia, Parma and Trieste fed into and substantially contributed to the national and international movement of 1968. In 1978 a law was passed (the “Basaglia law”) which sanctioned the closure of the entire Italian asylum system.
The first comprehensive study of this revolutionary approach to mental health care, The Man Who Closed the Asylums is a gripping account of one of the most influential movements in twentieth-century psychiatry, which helped to transform the way we see mental illness. Basaglia’s work saved countless people from a miserable existence, and his legacy persists, as an object lesson in the struggle against the brutality and ignorance that the establishment peddles to the public as common sense.
The Man Who Closed the Asylums took me a long time to read.  It's nearly 400 pages long and quite detailed.  At first I was fascinated with the story; after a while I was overwhelmed with the length and level of detail.  I'm not at all saying that it's a bad book--I think the research and the writing are very good--but that it's probably suited for a small audience.

I expected to read more about the conditions within the asylums and how those were addressed directly before the institutions were closed.  Instead, this book is more about interactions among mental health professionals and politicians.  A lot of doctors and politicians:  after a while I couldn't keep track of their names, much less who were allies, who disagreed with whom, and who supported which solution.

The research is meticulous and impeccable.  References are provided in footnotes.  I'm inclined to think that this book is the most deeply researched and detailed account of Franco Basaglia and the movement to close the mental asylums in Italy.  So I can't make a clear-cut recommendation:  I think it's an excellent book, but it's not for everyone.



(This Amazon.com link is an affiliate link.  If you click through and complete a purchase, I will receive a small commission.  Thank you for supporting my blog!)

0 Comments :

Post a Comment

I love to hear what you're thinking, so thank you for leaving a comment!

Spammers are unwelcome here, and spam comments will be deleted.

ShareThis